Epilepsy in the Irish Wolfhound
Margret L. Casal Dr med. vet, PhD1, Richard Munuve BVM1,
M. Anne Janis MS2, Petra Werner Dr med vet1, Paula Henthorn PhD1
From the 1Section of Medical Genetics, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of Pennsylvania and the 2Irish Wolfhound Seizure Study, Inc.
Acknowledgements: The authors thank the Jacky Karpinski fund and the Irish Wolfhound Seizure Study fundraisers for financial assistance and the owners and breeders for submitting the information needed for this retrospective study. The Irish Wolfhound Seizure Study, Inc. is a non-profit organization.
During the last fifteen years, an increase in the proportion of Irish Wolfhounds with seizure disorders has been observed.Clinical data and pedigrees from closely related Irish wolfhounds were collected retrospectively and analyzed. Idiopathic epilepsy was diagnosed, by exclusion of other causes for seizures, in 146 of 796 Irish wolfhounds (18.3%) from 115 litters. Males were more commonly affected than females (61.6% versus 38.4%), and life expectancy of affected dogs was decreased by two years when compared to the average Irish wolfhound population. The heritability index for the affected dogs, their littermates and unaffected parents was 0.87. The first seizure occurred by age 3 years in 73% of all dogs and there appeared to be a difference in the inheritance pattern between dogs with “early” and “late” onset seizures. In the group with “early onset” seizures, heritability increased slightly (0.88), and the gender bias was no longer significant. An autosomal recessive mode of inheritance, with incomplete penetrance and a possible sex-predilection, most simply explains the segregation of epileptic dogs in the pedigrees examined.
A seizure is defined as “an occasional sudden, excessive, rapid, and local discharge of gray matter” and may be generalized or partial 1. Idiopathic epilepsy is the predominant diagnosis in dogs with generalized, recurring seizures. Occasionally, some dogs with idiopathic epilepsy may only experience focal seizures or may even retain consciousness during the seizure. In the overall dog population 0.5 – 5.7% 2have seizures.
Idiopathic epilepsy has been described in a variety of dog breeds and has been suspected or shown to be a genetic disease 2. Various modes of inheritance of epilepsy have been deduced in different breeds, including simple autosomal recessive 3 with a sex-modifier 4, 5, polygenic recessive 6 with a sex-predilection 7, polygenic with a large contribution by a single autosomal recessive gene 8, and a multi-locus model 9.
Over the years a variety of medications have become available for the treatment of idiopathic epilepsy in humans but only a handful have been tested and approved for use in the dog 10. Unfortunately therapy is not always successful, which often leads to euthanasia of affected dogs 11. To reduce the number of losses, the disease should be eliminated from the breed population, which can be achieved with carefully designed breeding programs. However, in order to develop such programs the mode of inheritance needs to be understood and tests to determine carrier status must be developed.
The purposes of this study were to document idiopathic epilepsy and define the mode of inheritance in the Irish wolfhound. Information on affected and related, non-affected Irish wolfhounds collected by questionnaire and pedigree analysis are presented here.
Materials and Methods
Medical records and pedigree information from 120 litters (N=706) of Irish wolfhounds and their parents were obtained from veterinarians and owners by detailed questionnaire including requests for relevant laboratory reports. The diagnosis of idiopathic epilepsy in the 146 affected dogs was based on a history of more than two seizures in the absence of other medical problems, as defined by normal physical and neurological examinations, as well as normal hematological, serum biochemical, and urine analyses. Additional information collected included date of birth, gender, age of first observed seizure, number of known seizures, age at death, and cause of death. Owners of epileptic dogs also provided information on the seizure characteristics, such as observation of partial or generalized motor problems, urination, defecation, salivation, collapse and relationship of seizure onset to the time of day, feeding, walking, sleeping or estrus cycle. Necropsies were performed on 11 affected dogs at the Veterinary School of the University of Pennsylvania, Department of Pathobiology and one at the Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary Medicine, Department of Biomedical Sciences and Pathobiology. Dogs were considered phenotypically unaffected if no seizure had been observed during the dog’s lifetime. Seizure-free dogs that died before age four were not included in the data analysis and 37 dogs that had seizures in the presence of seizure-associated conditions or diseases, such as hyperthermia, portosystemic shunts, head trauma, or brain/neurological lesions, such as neoplasia and ehrlichiosis, were excluded from the study.
Pedigrees were examined from dogs with clear identifiers such as date of birth, age at death, gender, and known health status of littermates. Dogs were considered phenotypically unaffected if no seizure had been seen in absence of an underlying brain/neurological lesion by four years of age or by the time of their death. The vertical pedigrees were drawn and scrutinized to see whether the phenotypes and the assumed genotypes in each generation were compatible with expectations under assumptions of the simple Mendelian modes of inheritance. Segregation analysis was performed to correct for incomplete ascertainment 12 and heritability was calculated using standard methods 13
Idiopathic epilepsy was diagnosed in 146 (18.3%) Irish wolfhounds from 120 related litters containing 796 dogs. For females, the ages of their first observed seizure ranged from 6 months to 84 months (mean=27.6±16.8). The incidence of females with onset of seizures between 3 and 4 years of age was very low, with the majority (82%) of first observed seizures occurring before 3 years of age (hereafter to be referred to as “early” onset seizures versus “late” onset seizures beginning after age 3). The age of onset for males ranged from 6 months to 107 months (mean=33.9±18.5; Figure 1). Only 67% of males experienced their first seizure before the age of 3 years (“early onset”), whereas the onset of seizures occurred by 4 years of age in 83% of all male dogs. Overall, significantly more dogs had their first seizure before 3 years of life than after three years (p
(see Figure 1 at left: Number of dogs at various ages at first seizure.) Statistically significant differences in the age of onset of seizures (p
The ratio of affected male dogs (90) to female (56) was 1:0.62, differing significantly from the 1:1.08 male to female ratio for the general Irish wolfhound population during the same time period (p=0.001; an average of 2502 dogs were born yearly). In the “early onset” group the ratio of affected males to females (60:46) was not significantly different (p=0.27) from the general wolfhound population.
The coefficient of inbreeding was calculated for 5 and 10 generations and was examined with respect to the age of onset of disease in all dogs as well as in males and females separately. There was no significant correlation between age at first seizure and the coefficient of inbreeding, regardless of gender, or in all dogs considered together (R2 = 0.02-0.06). However, in 23 litters with multiple affected dogs, the onset of seizures in littermates occurred within 12 months of each other with the exception of seven litters in which one dog of each litter had its first seizure later in life. In the single instance where affected full siblings were born in separate litters (2 affected dogs in each of two litters) , the age of first seizure covered a range of 3 years (18, 31, 39, and 54 months,).
The prodromal signs observed by owners or breeders in affected dogs included: teeth chattering, anxiety, mental detachment (”spaciness”), standing with a blank stare, wandering aimlessly, increased attention seeking, and sitting or lying down immediately before a seizure. Interestingly, some owners observed “aberrant” behavior as puppies or months before the first seizure. Reported aberrant behaviors included the dog submerging its entire head when drinking, sound and touch sensitivity, shyness of doors or other barriers, exaggerated flight distance, and shyness to an approaching perceived threat. Affected males were often reported to be hyperactive and hard to control while females were commonly reported as being withdrawn and unable to relax.
The clinical signs were generalized seizures, as defined by uncontrolled muscular activity. All but four of the affected animals in this study experienced recurring grand mal seizures, with seizure duration varying from 30 seconds to 4 minutes. Six of the affected dogs began with mild generalized seizures that progressed to grand mal seizures over the course of their disease. Two animals were reported as having petit mal seizures and another two exhibited the “fly biting” type of seizure. In most dogs (38.4%) seizure episodes occurred during sleep regardless of time of day. In other dogs (13.7%), seizure episodes were reported to occur only while awake and active. In 22.6% of the affected dogs, the seizures occurred both during sleep and while awake. For 37 (25.3%) affected dogs this information was not recorded by the owner. The duration of each seizure in a particular dog was variable and was not predictive for the following seizure. Also, types of seizures were variable within the litters with multiple affected dogs. One affected dog had cluster seizures from the onset of disease, while the condition advanced from single grand mal seizures to cluster seizures in 29 affected Irish wolfhounds. While the “late onset” seizures were mainly classified as grand mal type seizures, they subjectively appeared to be milder and less frequent than seizures in the “early onset” dogs. In general, cluster seizures did occur in the “late onset” population of dogs but they were less common and the dogs required less medical treatment. Owners of multiple seizuring dogs described the “late onset” seizure dogs as having a better quality of life.
The postictal phase was characterized by wandering aimlessly, disorientation and confusion, running into stationary objects, and increased hunger. Almost all of the dogs with cluster seizures showed a prolonged recovery phase lasting more than 36 hours. A change in general behavior was noted in 13 dogs after the onset of disease. Recorded changes included sensitivity to noise (4 dogs) and light (1 dog), loss of vision (3 dogs), and shyness toward strangers (5 dogs).
There was no significant difference in longevity after the first seizure between affected males and females at p14. Of the 126 affected dogs that have died, 76 deaths (60.3%) were directly attributed to the seizure disorder, with the cause of death reported as death during seizure (16.1% of all seizure related deaths) or euthanasia because of uncontrolled seizures (65.8%), hepatotoxicity from phenobarbital treatment (6.6%), aspiration during seizures leading to fatal pneumonia (6.6%), or euthanasia because of non-recovery after a seizure (3.9%). Fifty affected dogs died of unrelated causes and 20 affected dogs were still alive at the time of writing. Detailed necropsies were performed on 12 of the affected Irish wolfhounds that were included in the study. No neurological or systemic lesions were found in these 12 dogs that could explain the recurrent seizures.
(see Figure 2 at left: Life expectancy plotted against age at first seizure (± SEM).) There was no statistically significant difference between any of the groups (p
A relatively large number of the affected dogs (36.6%) were not receiving any medication. Conventional maintenance therapy of phenobarbital, potassium bromide, clorazepate, dilantin or diazepam was used alone or in combination for the majority of affected dogs. Phenobarbital was by far the most commonly used drug for amelioration of the seizures, with 30.8% of all affected dogs receiving this drug. In 13.7% of the animals, phenobarbital was used in combination or alternately with potassium bromide. Potassium bromide alone was used in only 4 dogs (2.7%). Gabapentins were used experimentally in 3 animals. Two animals were treated with a combination of conventional and alternative therapies. Four individuals were treated with homeopathic therapy alone. None of the treatments eliminated the seizure activity but treatment was reported by owners to reduce frequency and severity of the seizures in the affected dogs. Interestingly, there was no discernable difference in the frequency or severity of seizures with the use of homeopathy as compared to conventional maintenance therapy. Side effects were reported from potassium bromide (ataxia; 1 dog) and phenobarbital (hepatotoxicity and motor dysfunction; 5 dogs). Response to therapy within litters with multiple affected dogs was not consistent, as each dog reacted differently to the same drugs given.
Affected dogs were present in 115 litters containing 773 dogs. Five litters (23 dogs) without affected dogs were born to matings between parents that had both been known to produce affected offspring. A representative portion of the larger pedigree illustrating the inheritance of idiopathic epilepsy is shown in Figure 3. The average inbreeding coefficient (calculated over ten generations) for all the dogs entered into the study was 0.156 with a range of 0.0353 – 0.35. The major observation made from examining the pedigree was that the vast majority of affected dogs were born to healthy parents (143 affected dogs from 112 litters). In keeping with this observation the trait was observed to skip generations. In 37 of the litters born to unaffected parents, one of the unaffected parents was related to other affected dogs. Only 3 of the affected dogs had an affected parent, and breedings between an affected and an unaffected parent could produce either all unaffected offspring or a mix of affected and unaffected offspring in the same litter. The segregation ratio and the heritability (h2) were calculated from litters in which both parents never had a history of seizures and in which medical information was available on all littermates. Ascertainment bias was corrected for using the singles method, as adopted by Nicholas 1987 13. The analysis for all dogs resulted in an h2 of 0.87 and an estimated segregation ratio of 0.083 ± 0.0001, which is significantly lower than would be expected from a fully penetrant autosomal recessive trait. Because of the potential difference between “early” and “late” onset seizures, the values were recalculated using only affected dogs that had their first seizure before 36 months. The h2 for the “early onset” group increased only slightly to 0.88 and the estimated segregation ratio increased to 0.095 ± 0.0002.
(see Figure 3 at left: Small portion of the much larger pedigree of Irish wolfhounds with idiopathic epilepsy.) Squares and circles represent males and females, respectively. Open and filled-in symbols designate normal dogs and affected wolfhounds, respectively. While not always indicated, all dogs in this pedigree have common ancestors.
Idiopathic epilepsy has been described in a variety of dog breeds along with different apparent or suspected modes of inheritance. A familial predisposition had been recognized early on in keeshonds, terriers, corgis, retrievers, pointers, setters, spaniels, collies, Alsatian dogs, boxers, Pekinese15, 16, Tervueren shepherds 17, dachshunds 15,16, 18, and in the Horak laboratory dog 19. Subsequently, epilepsy has been the subject of investigation in many institutions. In the German shepherd and in the keeshond, idiopathic epilepsy was thought to have a simple autosomal recessive basis 3, 20-22. Epilepsy in beagles was thought to be homologous to Lafora’s disease in man based on the similar findings from histopathological examination 23 and the mode of inheritance was described as autosomal recessive with a sex-linked “suppressor” 4, 5. For epilepsy in the golden retriever, a multifactorial etiology, including genetic and environmental factors has been described 9. Larger studies were performed in the Labrador retriever, Bernese mountain dog, and the Belgian tervueren. Pedigrees from 44 families with 55 epileptic Labrador retrievers were analyzed and the results were suggestive of a polygenic, recessive mode of inheritance 6. Analysis of pedigrees from 4005 Bernese mountain dogs with 50 affected dogs revealed a polygenic, recessive mode of inheritance with a predisposition for males 7. The Tervueren has been described as the dog breed with one of the highest incidences of seizures 17, 24. It is, therefore, no surprise that a number of genetic studies have been performed in this breed, with results proposing a single major gene with a large effect on seizures 8, 24-26. This is the first report of hereditary epilepsy in the Irish wolfhound breed.
In our study, an 18.3% incidence of idiopathic epilepsy was found among related Irish wolfhounds with a high heritability of 0.87 for the trait. These results suggest the presence of a major gene, as the heritability was higher than 0.5. The heritability did not change significantly if only dogs with “early onset” seizures were used in the calculations. In a similarly performed study a heritability of 0.77 was estimated in the Belgian Tervueren and 0.76 for the Belgian sheepdog 8. In the Irish wolfhounds, significantly more males were affected than females. This is in contrast to all but two other studies in which no sex predilection was found 3, 6, 8, 9. The results in the Irish wolfhounds are similar to the findings in the beagle and the Bernese mountain dog 4, 5, 7, where the involvement of a sex-modifier gene was hypothesized. However, when only those dogs with onset of seizure activity before 3 years of age were taken into account, there was not a significant difference between the percentage of affected females and males.
The age at first seizure ranged from 6 months to almost nine years of age in the affected Irish wolfhounds, with the majority (73.8%) of first seizures occurring at or before three years of age. These results are similar to what has been found in the general canine population 2, 27 and in specific breeds 6, 7, 9. In contrast, a study in Danish Labrador retrievers showed that the majority of seizures occurring before 4 years of age were only partial seizures and an equal number of generalized seizures occurred before and after four years of age 28. In beagles, the age of onset ranged from 11 to 70 months of age with 75% of the seizures occurring before the age of 40 months, which is at a slightly older age than in the Irish wolfhounds 4. However, the number of beagles examined was much smaller than the Irish wolfhounds in this study (29 versus 146). In the Irish wolfhounds, there was no correlation between the type or onset of seizure and the coefficient of inbreeding, similar to the findings in the Labrador and the Bernese mountain dog 6, 7.
Most of the Irish wolfhounds had clinical signs and grand mal type seizures, consistent with findings in almost all other studied dog breeds 2, 4, 7, 9, 27. However, grand mal seizures advanced to cluster seizures in 29 (19.9%) of the affected Irish wolfhounds, which is a large number considering that only 27% of all dogs referred for the treatment of cluster seizures suffer from (primary) idiopathic epilepsy 29. It is possible that the Irish wolfhounds have a more severe form of idiopathic epilepsy than has been previously reported in other breeds.
Similar to affected dogs of other breeds, none of the therapies eliminated the seizures completely, but the frequency and severity of the clinical signs were reduced in most Irish wolfhounds. Six dogs in the study exhibited side effects from their therapy which resulted in death in five dogs; a finding which has been described previously 30. Poor response to treatment has been attributed to inadequate drug therapy 11, 27, 29 and unresponsiveness to therapy 8.
Irish wolfhounds with idiopathic epilepsy had a life expectancy that was decreased by two years in comparison to the general Irish wolfhound population14. Of the affected dogs that died, 62% succumbed to disorders of quality of life issues directly attributable to idiopathic epilepsy. These losses and the decreased life expectancy underscore the need for elimination of the disease from the breed by implementing a selective breeding program.
Pedigree examination revealed several features supporting an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance. A simple dominant mode of inheritance can be excluded because the vast majority of affected dogs were born to clinically normal parents. An X-linked mode of inheritance must be entertained because the incidence of seizures in males was significantly higher than in females. However, almost all of the affected females were born to clinically normal parents; in an X-linked trait one would expect affected females to be born from affected males bred to carrier females. The estimated segregation ratio is not consistent with a fully penetrant simple autosomal recessive mode of inheritance. It was therefore concluded that seizures in the Irish wolfhounds are inherited as a non-fully penetrant autosomal recessive trait with a sex predilection for males in all of the affected dogs and as a non-fully penetrant autosomal recessive trait without a sex predilection in the “early onset” group.
Genetic studies in humans and mice with idiopathic epilepsy have revealed a number of causative genes for specific forms of epilepsy 31. Mutations for monogenic epilepsies have been found primarily in genes coding for ion channels 32 as well as in two different proteins that may be involved in neurogenesis 33. More recently, the molecular basis for autosomal recessive progressive myoclonic epilepsy (Lafora disease) in the miniature wirehaired dachshund has been identified 34. However, this well- defined form of epilepsy (not idiopathic), which is characterized by myoclonic type seizures with rapid, progressive mental deterioration and polyglucosan intracellular inclusions 35, is clearly distinct from the form or forms of epilepsy observed in Irish wolfhounds and other breeds. In considering the genetic bases for epilepsy in various dog breeds, including Irish wolfhounds it is important to consider that most forms of idiopathic generalized epilepsy in humans are inherited as complex genetic traits 36. A more recent study in humans has demonstrated a major susceptibility gene with modifiers that influence the clinical appearance of the seizure 37. We suspect that a similar mechanism is responsible for the phenotypic appearance of idiopathic epilepsy in the Irish wolfhound. Given the high heritability of epilepsy in this breed, linkage analysis studies to determine the genes involved are feasible.
The high incidence of seizures in the Irish wolfhound along with the decreased longevity in affected animals and unsatisfactory treatment modalities underscore the need for a breeding program designed to eliminate the disease from the breed. Documentation of the inheritance pattern of the disease is important not only in designing such a program, but also in performing additional genetic studies that can lead to the development DNA-based genetic tests for the identification of disease predisposing alleles, which can greatly enhance the efficiency of such a program.
© 2005 Margret Casal, Dr med vet, PhD, et.al.
All rights reserved. Reprint requests to be directed to email@example.com
1. Mattson RH. Overview: Idiopathic generalized epilepsies. Eplilepsia 2003; 44:2-6
2. Cunningham JG and Farnbach GC. Inheritance and idiopathic canine epilepsy. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc 1988;24:421-424
3. Hall SJG and Wallace ME. Canine epilepsy: a genetic counseling programme for keeshonds. Vet Rec 1996; 138:358-360
4. Bielfelt SW, Redman HC, and McClellan RO. Sire and sex-related differences in rates of epileptiform seizures in a purebred beagle dog colony. Am J Vet Res 1971;32:2039-2048
5. Edmonds HL, Hegreberg GA, van Gelder NM, et al. Spontaneous convulsions in beagle dogs. Fed Proc 1979;38:2424-2428
6. Jaggy A, Faissler D, Gaillard C, et al. Genetic aspects of idiopathic epilepsy in Labrador retrievers. J Small Anim Pract 1998;39:275-80
7. Kathmann I, Jaggy A, Busato A, et al. Clinical and genetic investigations of idiopathic epilepsy in the Bernese mountain dog. J Small Anim Pract 1999;40:319-25
8. Oberbauer AM, Grossman DI, Irion DN, et al. The genetics of epilepsy in the Belgian tervuren and sheepdog. J Hered 2003;94:57-63
9. Srenk P, Jaggy A, Gaillard C, et al. [Genetic basis of idiopathic epilepsy in the golden retriever]. Tierarztl Prax 1994;22:574-8
10. Dowling PM. Update on therapy of canine epilepsy. Can Vet J 1999;40:595-8
11. Schwartz-Porsche D. Lack of success in the treatment of epilepsy - faulty therapy or resistance to treatment? Dtsch tierärztl Wschr 1992;99:407-410
12. Davie AH. The singles method for segregation analysis under incomplete ascertainment. Ann Hum Genet 1979;42:507
13. Nicholas FW. Is it inherited? Veterinary Genetics, Oxford: Claredon Press; 1987:217-231.
14. Bernardi G. Longevity and morbidity in the Irish wolfhound in the United States from 1966-1986. AKC Gazette 1986;105:70-78
15. Croft PG and Stockman MJR. Inherited defects in dogs. Vet Rec 1964;76:260-261
16. Croft PG. Fits in dogs: A survey of 260 cases. Vet Rec 1965;77:438-445
17. Van der Velden NA. Fits in Tervueren Shepherd dogs: A presumed hereditary trait. J Small Anim Pract 1968;9:63-70
18. Holliday TA, Cunningham JG, and Gutnick MJ. Comparative clinical and electroencephalographic studies of canine epilepsy. Eplilepsia 1970;11:281-292
19. Martinek Z and Horak F. Spontanepilepsie bei Hunden: Langzeituntersuchungen an einer Gruppe genetisch verwandter Tiere. Zbl Vet Med A 1977; 24:353-371
20. Lawler DC. Epilepsy in dogs (letter). NZ Vet J 1970;18:53
21. Falco MJ, Barker J, and Wallace ME. The genetics of epilepsy in the British Alsatian. J Small Anim Pract 1974;15:685-692
22. Wallace ME. Keeshonds: a genetic study of epilepsy and EEG readings. J Small Anim Pract 1975;16:1-10
23. Hegreberg GA and Padgett GA. Inherited progressive epilepsy of the dog with comparisons to Lafora's disease of man. Fed Proc 1976;35:1202-1205
24. Famula TR and Oberbauer AM. Reducing the incidence of epileptic seizures in the Belgian Tervuren through selection. Prev Vet Med 1998; 33:251-9
25. Famula TR, Oberbauer AM, and Brown KN. Heritability of epileptic seizures in the Belgian tervueren. J Small Anim Pract 1997;38:349-52
26. Famula TR and Oberbauer AM. Segregation analysis of epilepsy in the Belgian tervueren dog. Vet Rec 2000;147:218-21
27. Raw M-E and Gaskell CJ. A review of one hundred cases of presumed canine epilepsy. J Small Anim Pract 1985;26:645-652
28. Berendt M, Gredal H, Pedersen LG, Alban L, and Alving J. A cross-sectional study of epilepsy in the Danish Labrador retrievers: Prevalence and selected risk factors. J Vet Int Med 2002;16:262-268
29. Bateman SW and Parent JM. Clinical findings, treatment, and outcome of dogs with status epilepticus or cluster seizures: 156 cases (1990-1995). J Am Vet Med Assoc 1999;215:1463-1468
30. Thomas WB. Idiopathic epilepsy in dogs. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 2000;30:183-206, vii
31. Meisler MH, Ottman KJ, and Escayg A. Identification of epilepsy genes in human and mouse. Ann Rev Genet 2001;35:567 - 588
32. Scheffer IE and Berkovic SF. The genetics of human epilepsy. Trends Pharmacol Sci 2003;24:428-33
33. Scheel H, Tomiuk S, and Hofmann K. A common protein interaction domain links two recently identified epilepsy genes. Hum Mol Genet 2002;11:1757-62
34. Lohi H, Young EJ, Fitzmaurice SN, et al. Expanded repeat in canine epilepsy. Science 2005;307:81
35. Serratosa JM, Gomez-Garre P, Gallardo ME, et al. A novel protein tyrosine phosphatase gene is mutated in progressive myoclonus epilepsy of the Lafora type (EPM2). Hum Mol Genet 1999;8:345-52
36. Sander T, Schulz H, Saar K, et al. Genome search for susceptibility loci of common idiopathic generalised epilepsies. Hum Mol Genet 2000;9:1465-72
37. Durner M, Keddache MA, Tomasini L, et al. Genome scan of idiopathic generalized epilepsy: Evidence for major susceptibility gene and modifying genes influencing the seizure type. Ann Neurol 2001;49:328-335